2027 NFL Draft Mailbag: Quarterback concerns, rising prospects and more
By Jack Brentnall
With the college football regular season entering its final weeks, it felt like the right time to open up the mailbag.
The response was bigger than I expected, so I’ve split the answers into two articles, with the second part to follow soon.
This first instalment covers the struggles of the quarterback class, the depth at receiver, and biggest surprises from summer scouting.
Thanks to everyone who sent questions in, and if yours isn’t answered here, keep an eye out for part two.
Which position group has dropped off the most for you since the start of the season?
I’d probably go with offensive tackle, although edge is another position that comes to mind.
Trevor Goosby and Jordan Seaton were two of the tackles I was most excited about entering the season, but neither has quite delivered. Goosby was disappointing before suffering his season-ending injury, while Seaton has shown flashes without taking the developmental leap I was hoping to see following his move to LSU. I still expect Seaton to be a first round pick, but I wanted to see more growth.
Utah’s Zereoue Williams has been the real bright spot at the position, coming out of nowhere to be my current OT1.
Edge is another contender, although for different reasons. Dylan Stewart and Colin Simmons have largely lived up to expectations, but the depth behind them hasn’t developed as I’d hoped. Players like Damon Wilson and Yhonzae Pierre looked like they might make big leaps this year, but neither has really taken that step.
Ultimately, the disappointment at the top of the offensive tackle class gives it the edge for me.
Do you believe more quarterbacks or wide receivers will be drafted in the first round? And what about the top 100?
Wide receivers, comfortably. And that applies to both. I’ve long felt this quarterback class was overhyped. Some of the players I was optimistic about have disappointed, while I’ve been lower than consensus on others, including Darian Mensah, Trinidad Chambliss and LaNorris Sellers, from the outset.
There are probably only one or two quarterbacks I’d be comfortable taking in the first round. Quarterback inflation means I could see three being selected, but I’d be surprised if there were more.
Wide receiver looks considerably stronger. Jeremiah Smith is the obvious headliner, but I’m also high on Nick Marsh, Charlie Becker and Jackson Harris. Deuce Alexander has first round potential, while Cam Coleman could still go high if he declares, despite the frustrating inconsistency of his tape at Texas. I can easily envisage four or five first round receivers.
I’m even more confident about the top 100. Teams tend to invest heavily in quarterbacks early or wait until later in the draft. Just eight quarterbacks have been selected between picks 51 and 100 over the past five drafts.
Wide receivers, meanwhile, tend to fly off the board throughout Day 2. The depth of this class should make that trend continue.
Which players currently out for the season through injury do you think will declare for the 2027 NFL Draft, and which will return to school?
With the financial opportunities available through NIL, I think we’ll see plenty of injured prospects choose to return to school rather than enter the draft with their stock potentially diminished.
That said, I’ve got a sneaky feeling Dante Moore might declare. He already passed on the opportunity to enter the NFL last year, and his injury raises the question of whether he wants to risk returning again. In a relatively weak quarterback class, he could still attract first round interest.
I’d lean towards Trevor Goosby returning to Texas. I wasn’t particularly impressed with his performances before the injury, and another season could help him rebuild his stock.
I’d also expect LSU safety Dashawn Spears to return. He’s certainly less of a household name, but was a player I really liked entering the season. He will want to get a full season as a starter under his belt before he declares.
Tennessee edge Tyree Weathersby is another interesting case following his breakout season and subsequent injury, although I’d lean towards him returning too. The other name I can think of is Nico Iamaleava, whose camp has already indicated that he intends to return to UCLA.
What are your thoughts on Cooper Barkate as a prospect?
I’m a fan of Cooper Barkate, although I think there are limitations that will prevent him from becoming a genuine difference-maker at the next level.
He’s a polished, detailed route runner who understands how to attack leverage and work into defensive backs’ blind spots. There’s a craftiness to his game that I appreciate, and he’s got good long speed. Miami has done a nice job of manufacturing touches for him on screens and designed plays, and he’s been effective in those situations..
My biggest concern is his play strength. He’s relatively lean and can struggle against bigger, more physical corners. Those limitations have shown up against players like Leonard Moore and Ashton Hampton.
For that reason, I see him primarily as a Z receiver in the NFL, where he can play off the line of scrimmage and avoid consistent exposure to press coverage.
He’s polished, dependable and has the tools to be a reliable chain mover, even if I don’t necessarily see a high-end ceiling. I’ve currently got a mid-third round grade on him.
Who's your WR2 behind Jeremiah Smith right now?
As things stand, it’s Indiana’s Nick Marsh, although there’s very little separating him and Charlie Becker. Ultimately, it comes down to what flavour of receiver you prefer.
I’m a big fan of Marsh’s combination of prototypical size, explosiveness and technical refinement. He’s a nuanced route runner who shows good technique with his releases and understands how to attack defensive backs.
What particularly appeals to me is his ability after the catch. That combination of size and YAC ability is something I always value highly.
I see him as a traditional X receiver who can win downfield but also be a creative weapon underneath. There’s even potential for him to contribute as a big slot or power slot.
Becker is right there alongside him, though. It’s an incredibly close race for WR2, and I suspect it will remain that way throughout the season.
Which quarterbacks do you like in the first round of the 2027 NFL Draft?
It’s a difficult question because there isn’t a quarterback in this class I’d be banging the table for as a definite franchise player.
If I were the GM of a quarterback-needy team and had to select someone, though, I’d go with Missouri’s Austin Simmons, assuming he declares.
He’s the quarterback I’m most comfortable betting on, although I think there’s a strong argument for him returning to school and continuing his development.
Beyond Simmons, I could potentially get on board with Drew Mestemaker towards the end of the first round, but his recent performances have concerned me. I thought he struggled again against Texas Tech last weekend, albeit while dealing with a shoulder injury for part of the game.
I certainly don’t share the view that Mestemaker should be a top five or top ten selection. I think we’re so desperate for a quarterback to emerge as the headline name of this class that there’s a danger of forcing that narrative.
Ultimately, Simmons would be my choice, but even then, I’d have reservations.
Which player has surprised you the most this season, both positively and negatively?
Negatively, it’s Arch Manning. I was pretty vocal about believing he was comfortably the best quarterback in this class entering the season, so his regression has been particularly disappointing.
His decision making looks worse, his internal clock has deteriorated, and he simply hasn’t looked like the player I evaluated last year.
I’m not suggesting my summer evaluation was necessarily correct. I may well have overestimated his processing ability and pocket presence. But I also think there’s been a genuine decline in his performances, and the scale of that drop-off has surprised me.
Positively, I’ll go with Alabama defensive lineman Devan Thompkins. I had him 127th on my preseason board with a sixth round grade after being relatively underwhelmed by his USC tape.
However, Alabama seems to have brought the best out of him. He’s looked explosive and athletic, with violent hands, excellent pad level and a clear pass rush plan.
There are still questions about his NFL role given his hybrid edge/interior profile, but he’s a player I’m considerably higher on now than I was over the summer.
How do character concerns affect your scouting grades?
Character concerns absolutely factor into my grading process, although I think it’s important to recognise the limitations we have as independent evaluators.
We’re not in the building, conducting interviews or speaking to coaches. That’s why I only account for publicly verified incidents, such as arrests, suspensions or dismissals from a programme. I’m not going to downgrade someone based on rumours circulating within the draft community.
As with injuries, I have a system for factoring these concerns into my grades, with the severity of the issue determining the deduction.
I also consider the level of investment involved. I’d be more willing to overlook certain concerns with a fifth round prospect than someone I’m considering as a potential franchise cornerstone. Some of the worst draft busts in recent years have come as a result of a team overlooking character concerns with a premium pick.
Ultimately, missing on a first round pick because of character concerns is considerably more damaging than missing on a fifth rounder, so that additional risk is reflected in the grade.
Who has been your biggest hit from summer scouting?
I’d probably go with Georgia linebacker Chris Cole. Cole was 44th on the consensus big board entering the season, but I had him 20th overall and comfortably ranked as my LB1.
What appealed to me was his potential as a complete linebacker. He had ideal length, showed a high ceiling in coverage and offered intriguing versatility as a blitzer, alongside encouraging flashes against the run.
Admittedly, it was a projection based on a relatively small sample size, given he hadn’t been a full-time starter. However, I felt the flashes suggested we were only scratching the surface of his potential. He’s since climbed into the top ten of the consensus rankings.

JACK BRENTNALL
HEAD OF NFL DRAFT CONTENT
Previously the founder of The Jet Sweep, Jack joined The Touchdown as head of Draft Content in 2024. A Scouting Academy alumnus, Jack has been Covering the NFL Draft since 2020. Follow him on Twitter @Jack_Brentnall.
