Week 11 Scouting Notebook: Jelani McDonald's three-pick night, Drew Mestemaker's turnover problem and more
By Jack Brentnall
Week 11 gave the 2027 NFL Draft class another weekend of high level football to be judged on, with Texas-LSU the headline matchup and Oklahoma State-Texas Tech carrying plenty of intrigue of its own. Here is what stood out on tape.
A hat-trick of picks for Jelani McDonald
There are plenty of ways for a safety to influence a game, but intercepting three passes is a pretty effective place to start. Texas’ Jelani McDonald did exactly that against LSU, with two of his picks coming in the end zone as he played a pivotal role in the Longhorns’ win.
It could have been an even bigger night. McDonald dropped another interception early in the second quarter, leaving him close to a record-setting four-pick performance. The interceptions understandably commanded the attention, but his coverage intelligence showed up throughout. He was instinctive in zone all night, showing a good feel for route distribution and spacing as he helped limit LSU’s passing attack. He also had some impressive reps in man coverage against Trey’Dez Green, one of which resulted in an interception.
His coverage was the story, but McDonald was just as reliable against the run. He didn’t miss on any of his 10 tackle attempts and recorded four defensive stops.
McDonald was a player who I was perhaps a little lower on over the summer (he was No. 54 on my preseason board) but I have been very impressed by his play so far this season. This is a very talented safety class, and McDonald has certainly played his way into first-round contention as far as I am concerned.
You won’t find many better defensive performances than Jelani McDonald’s against LSU.
— Jack Brentnall (@Jack_Brentnall) November 16, 2026
10 tackles, four stops and three interceptions as he played a huge role in Texas’ win. I’ve been really impressed with him this season. pic.twitter.com/Y8z9Wz3fRa
Drew Mestemaker's tape does not match the hype
I understand why Drew Mestemaker has generated excitement. The Oklahoma State quarterback has good arm talent, and it’s easy to admire the confidence he plays with as a passer. He will attack tight windows, work the middle of the field with anticipation and give his receivers opportunities before they have created clear separation.
But his performance against Texas Tech continued a recent trend that leaves me unconvinced by the potential No. 1 overall talk. Mestemaker completed 26 of 40 passes for 259 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions. He left in the fourth quarter with a shoulder injury, by which point the game was already out of reach.
The problem is that there are too many times when that confidence gets ahead of his assessment of the coverage. Mestemaker repeatedly launched throws downfield against Texas Tech without ever stopping to confirm the post-snap picture. It was most evident when he got to the backside of a concept, and it cost him more than once.
What is equally frustrating is that he then has moments of conservatism, where he is content to check the ball down on third down rather than working tougher throws to move the chains. That inconsistency is to be expected given Mestemaker’s lack of experience, but it is hard to square with a top draft pick.
The numbers bear out those concerns too. Mestemaker has 19 turnover-worthy plays this season, the most among Power Four quarterbacks. Nine have come across his last three games, including five against Iowa State in Week 9.
There are mechanical issues to address too. His lower half does not consistently align with his target, contributing to some wild misses. There were multiple times against Texas Tech where he made the correct read, only to be let down by poor placement and mechanics.
Fans and the media are eager for a quarterback to emerge as the headline name of this class. My concern is that some of the discussion around Mestemaker is being driven more by that desire than his play on the field. The opportunity to become the top quarterback in a class does not, by itself, make someone a convincing No. 1 overall prospect. Given how he has looked over the last few weeks, I’m increasingly of the view that he should return for another season and continue to refine his game before going pro.
Aiden Flora and Cole Tabb trade big plays in Iowa State vs Cincinnati
If you enjoy watching explosive running backs, Iowa State’s meeting with Cincinnati was well worth your time. Iowa State’s Aiden Flora and Cincinnati’s Cole Tabb combined for 396 rushing yards and 93 receiving yards, with both players showing that they have the potential to flip the field on any given play.
Tabb wasted little time showing off his burst, taking his first carry for 66 yards. His acceleration is a real selling point, and he finished with 165 rushing yards on just 16 carries. He gained 113 of those yards after contact and forced six missed tackles. Tabb’s 9.1 yards per attempt leads all FBS running backs this season and he ranks ninth with 15 breakaway carries.
What particularly caught my attention, though, was his work on passing downs. Tabb caught eight passes for 70 yards, showing reliable hands and giving his quarterback a useful outlet underneath. There were also some encouraging pass protection reps. He is not the biggest back, but his eyes are good, and he showed an ability to identify his assignment and put himself in position to help.
That combination gives him a credible route to an NFL role. His burst can provide a change of pace on the ground, while his receiving and pass protection offer reasons to keep him involved on passing downs. He is still a true junior and could yet return to school.
Flora was just as entertaining on the other side and for my money is the more notable NFL Draft prospect. He rushed for 231 yards and three touchdowns on 30 carries, adding three catches for 23 yards. He forced 12 missed tackles, taking him to 56 on the season.
His track background was on full display. Flora cuts quickly and accelerates out of those changes of direction, which makes him a difficult player to corral. While his 195 lb frame is less than ideal, he does a really nice job of anticipating contact and preventing defenders from hitting him cleanly.
Flora has now rushed for 1,363 yards at 7.4 yards per carry this season, with 12 rushing touchdowns. Add in his ability to catch the ball and there is a lot to get excited about. He is a redshirt sophomore and I would be surprised if he declared, but he does have the opportunity to take advantage of what appears to be a weaker running back class.
Iowa State RB Aiden Flora had another huge game this weekend. 231 yards and three TDs on 30 carries vs Cincinnati.
— Jack Brentnall (@Jack_Brentnall) November 16, 2026
He’s a redshirt sophomore, so likely one for 2028, but the blend of speed and vision is really impressive. Ran a 10.61 100m in high school. pic.twitter.com/677gT8xhqF
AJ Holmes' bull rush gives Oklahoma State problems
AJ Holmes’ performance against Oklahoma State felt like another entry in an increasingly convincing body of work.
The Texas Tech defensive tackle finished with a respectable tally of three pressures and a sack, but his impact was greater than the box score might suggest. Oklahoma State limited his opportunities by keeping true pass sets to a minimum. Holmes saw only eight such reps but made them count, winning on 37.5% of them.
What stood out again this week was the effectiveness of Holmes’ bull rush. He has consistently shown himself to be capable of driving blockers backwards and creating problems for opposing quarterbacks, giving them little room to escape or reset. So far this season he has compiled 45 pressures and 10 sacks across 10 games.
The projection is less straightforward. Holmes lacks ideal length, which will invite questions about how effectively that disruption translates against NFL offensive linemen. As much as he has shown real growth this season, I do have concerns about whether he can be a genuine three-down player at the next level. That said, he should at the very least be an impactful weapon on passing downs, and that sort of skillset always carries value.
AJ Holmes had another really impressive game.
— Jack Brentnall (@Jack_Brentnall) November 16, 2026
His bull rush has been a problem for opposing offenses all season, and he makes his presence felt again here by collapsing the pocket and affecting Drew Mestemaker, resulting in the interception. pic.twitter.com/1IhRZSgaUV

JACK BRENTNALL
HEAD OF NFL DRAFT CONTENT
Previously the founder of The Jet Sweep, Jack joined The Touchdown as head of Draft Content in 2024. A Scouting Academy alumnus, Jack has been Covering the NFL Draft since 2020. Follow him on Twitter @Jack_Brentnall.
