Eight Divisions, Eight Decisions: Building the Ultimate 2026 NFL Super Team

By Paul Gould

This week, I’ve set myself an intriguing little challenge. Eight NFL divisions, eight categories, eight selections to build the ultimate super team. The catch? I can only pick from each division once.

The categories are QB, WR, TE, RB, Offensive Line, Defense, Kicker and Head Coach. That means some tough decisions, a few compromises and plenty of head-scratching as I try to assemble the strongest possible team.

My selections are based on performances so far this season, but with one eye on what lies ahead. So, who makes the cut, which divisions provide the goods, and where might I have gone wrong?

Here’s my thinking…

QB: Brock Purdy – NFC West

Embed from Getty Images

Naturally, when building any squad, finding a franchise quarterback is always top of the shopping list. This season, there are a number of excellent candidates who fit the bill, and I worked from a long list of nine – Josh Allen, Joe Burrow, Trevor Lawrence, C.J. Stroud, Caleb Williams, Jordan Love, Jared Goff, Bryce Young and Brock Purdy.

I quickly discounted Young due to Carolina’s recent struggles and then eliminated the NFC North trio, as I felt my selection for that division was better deployed elsewhere.

That left me with Burrow, Allen, Stroud, Lawrence and Purdy. Any of these would orchestrate an offense at the highest level. Of this quintet, only Josh Allen currently has an overall passer rating below 100 (97.8), so he was next off the list. And sticking with the average passer rating metric to guide me, I was left with a decision between the two QBs with the highest numbers – Joe Burrow (117.7) and Brock Purdy (115.2).

It’s been great to see Burrow operating injury-free. The result has been him throwing for the most touchdowns in the NFL and posting the highest completion percentage (74%), which has placed him firmly in the mix as an MVP candidate.

But in the final analysis, I went with Purdy. He’s been almost flawless this year and has had to contend with a litany of injuries impacting his receivers. His decision-making and ability to extend plays by evading pressure is beginning to draw parallels between him and Patrick Mahomes.

Taking Purdy as my QB also meant I could deploy my AFC North pick for the guy he would throw the ball to…

WR: Ja’Marr Chase – AFC North

Embed from Getty Images

This was another exceedingly tough choice with the contenders being Ja’Marr Chase, Tee Higgins, Zay Flowers, Parker Washington, CeeDee Lamb, Christian Watson, Matthew Golden, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Chris Olave, Drake London and Jaxson Smith-Njigba.

Statistically, JSN and Lamb are just ahead of Chase this season, but the domino effect that selecting either of them would have had on subsequent picks was messy. So, I pivoted to Chase, a pick I’m more than happy with.

Against the Steelers on Sunday night, Chase was imperious, posting the only 200-yard performance of any receiver so far in 2026. Many of these were generated after the catch, an aspect of Chase’s game in which he excels. He’s also ultra-reliable, dropping only two passes this year.

TE: Brock Bowers – AFC West

Embed from Getty Images

The competition to secure the tight end spot in my squad came down to a straight fight between the two dominant players in the position, Trey McBride and Brock Bowers.

I showered both with praise in my recent article marking National Tight Ends Day and went back and forth between them before making my choice. Both are integral pieces of struggling teams, and the fact that Bowers ranks 13th in receiving and McBride 17th – ahead of several quality wide receivers – is testament to their importance.

McBride is a player I always enjoy watching. He’s having another productive year in terms of catches and yardage. But the statistic that gives Bowers the edge is his touchdown total – Bowers has 11 to McBride’s four. Although he’s been hampered by injury this season, his ability to take over a game (and the fact he wears the Silver & Black) was enough to make up my mind.

RB: Bijan Robinson – NFC South

Embed from Getty Images

The running back position offered me the best value for my NFC South selection. Statistically, Robinson is the third-best rusher in the NFL so far in 2026, behind Jahmyr Gibbs and James Cook, but the margin separating them is small.

Operating in a Falcons team with a disappointing 3-7 record, Robinson is averaging over five yards per carry and has seven touchdowns to his name. He was the subject of an enquiry from the Giants at the trade deadline, and if the Falcons fail to make the playoffs, he will be among the best players in the league to miss out on postseason football.

Fellow NFC South star Bucky Irving and Chiefs RB Kenneth Walker III also made my shortlist but, ultimately, it was impossible to pass on a rusher of Robinson’s pedigree.

O-line: Buffalo Bills – AFC East

Embed from Getty Images

Among the top offensive lines this year are the 49ers, Lions and Steelers, all of whom tempted me here.

But with the divisions I had left available, the Bills’ offensive line stood out as the best option for this category. The line features Pro Bowl-calibre starters, including veteran left tackle Dion Dawkins, right guard O’Cyrus Torrence and center Connor McGovern.

The group has performed consistently all year, opening running lanes for James Cook to do his thing and protecting Josh Allen. Buffalo has allowed just 18 sacks so far, an average of two per game.

The Bills high-powered offense owes much to the unsung work done in the trenches, and the offensive line will play a vital role in achieving Buffalo’s aspirations in 2026.

Defense: Minnesota Vikings – NFC North

Embed from Getty Images

Having only conceded 126 points thus far, the Vikings’ defense remains on course to break the record for the fewest points allowed in a 17-game season (277 points, presently held by the 2022 49ers). They will probably fall short of threatening the 16-game record of 200 points set by the 2000 Ravens, but the 17-game record is certainly achievable.

Minnesota’s defense continues to be the stuff of nightmares for opposing offenses. They have only allowed more than 20 points on two occasions this season – 22 against the Packers in Week 1, and 23 against the Bills in Week 9. Given how explosive those offenses have been against other opponents, that’s no disgrace.

Their blitz rate of 73% is astonishing and teams continue to struggle to contain the Vikings’ pass rush. If there’s an area in which Minnesota’s defense can improve, it’s against the run but it would be churlish of me to dwell on that. With a respectful nod to Denver and Seattle, picking the Vikings for this category was probably my easiest decision in this process.

Kicker: Cam Little – AFC South

Embed from Getty Images

Tampa’s Chase McLaughlin and Buffalo’s Tyler Bass stood out for selection in this spot, as they’re the only two kickers yet to miss a field goal this season.

But, once again, this selection was dictated to some extent by the divisions left available to me. However, that’s not to detract in any way from the quality of Cam Little. I saw it with my own eyes when he kicked the game-winning field goal against the Eagles at Tottenham last month.

Little still holds the NFL record for the longest field goal in league history (68 yards) and he’s hit a 60-yarder this season. His success rate is a highly respectable 90% so far in 2026 and he has shown the mettle to make high-pressure kicks when required.

Head Coach: John Harbaugh – NFC East

Embed from Getty Images

If I hadn’t opted for Cam Little as my kicker, I might have used my AFC South pick to take Liam Coen as my head coach. Some pundits expected the Jaguars to be a regression candidate in 2026, but Jacksonville has continued to go from strength to strength.

A former offensive coordinator, Coen appears to have unlocked Trevor Lawrence and developed the players around him, such as Parker Washington and Bhayshul Tuten.

But, along with Todd Monken in Cleveland, the coach who has had the most transformative effect on a team this season is John Harbaugh with the New York Giants. Despite justified doubts about the overall quality of the NFC East, Harbaugh has done a sterling job in guiding the G-Men into first place at the halfway stage of the season.

He’s kept the team on track following the early loss of Jaxson Dart and is making strides in improving the culture and resilience of the locker room. So far, his hiring has proved to be an excellent decision. The Giants, and my fictitious team, appear to be in safe hands.

Gould’s Gladiators

QB – Brock Purdy (NFC West)

WR – Ja’Marr Chase (AFC North)

TE – Brock Bowers (AFC West)

RB – Bijan Robinson (NFC South)

O-line – Buffalo Bills (AFC East)

Defense – Minnesota Vikings (NFC North)

K – Cam Little (AFC South)

Head Coach – John Harbaugh (NFC East)

PAUL GOULD

NFL ANALYST

A freelance writer and editor based in Cambridgeshire, Paul has avidly followed the NFL since the late 1980’s and spends much of his spare time wondering if he’ll ever see the Raiders play in a Super Bowl again.

Rated 5 out of 5