The NFC South once again strikes as the NFL's strangest division
By Andy Davies
The NFC South was once one of the most dominant divisions in the NFL.
Founded in 2002, it is tied for the youngest division in the league. It saw its biggest peak in the 2010’s.
It was a decade filled with the excellence of Drew Brees at the New Orleans Saints and the dominance of Julio Jones at the Atlanta Falcons. Cam Newton and the Carolina Panthers had one of the greatest single seasons in NFL history.
In a decade that started with the Saints crowned Super Bowl champions in the February of 2010, the division winners averaged 10.8 wins a season. Four of those ten seasons saw the runner up have double digit win totals.
There were even back-to-back years of NFC South teams representing the conference in the Super Bowl, as the Panthers and Falcons made it all the way to the big dance in the 2015 and 2016 seasons respectively. Both were on the wrong end of the scoreline, but this was a division that was strong.
However, despite the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ early success in the 2020’s, this division has seen a downturn in quality.
Since the Buccaneers’ Super Bowl LV glory in the 2020 season and their 13-4 record during the following campaign, only one NFC South champion has had double digit wins. Two of these were losing seasons.
No runner up from the NFC South has made the playoffs since the Bucs hoisted the Lombardi Trophy at a Covid-hit Raymond James Stadium in February 2021. The division champions have gone 1-4 in the postseason during the past four seasons.
This season feels no different, with the Panthers currently leading the division with a 3-5 record. However, the fourth-place Falcons also have three wins.
Lacking the true talent all over, the NFC South is once again one of the strangest but tightest divisions that the league possesses.
A struggle for consistency
This has been the theme of the NFC South this season, and in truth, over the past four seasons. No team seems to want to win the division.
In 2023, the winner and runner-up of the division both had 9-8 records. In 2025, the top three teams had 8-9 records.
This season seems even more unpredictable, but not in a good way. This is despite Bijan Robinson having over 1,000 total yards and seven total touchdowns. Perhaps no team personifies this more than the Falcons. They started 2026 with two losses, including a horrific Week Two 34-3 loss to the Panthers. A road win against the Green Bay Packers and a 45-24 win over the Saints followed. They did lose to the Baltimore Ravens in overtime, but this was largely due to the Michael Penix Jr injury.
Across Weeks Seven and Eight, the Falcons managed to become the first teams to beat the San Francisco 49ers and lose 16-0 to a Bucs team that failed to throw a single completed pass.
Speaking of the Bucs, they started the season off 0-4, before winning three of their last five games. The Saints have failed to put two consecutive wins all season. Carolina started off 3-2, before just one win in their last four games.
The Falcons cannot seem to get a quarterback to stay healthy. New Orleans has had difficulties playing in all four quarters. Carolina have conceded 43 points or more in two games and scored over 30 points on two other occasions. Tampa Bay had the aforementioned 0-4 start. No team in the NFC South has been able to find that consistency.
Who wins the ultimate NFC South slog fest?
Every team in the NFC South has their case to be the ones who win the division.
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers possess the best defense out of the four teams, whilst arguably also the best quarterback in Baker Mayfield, when he wants to be.
In Atlanta, the Falcons have the best trio of offensive weapons in Robinson, Drake London, Kyle Pitts Sr. In Robinson, they have the best player in the entire NFC South. The best head coach might just be the Panthers’ Dave Canales, and quarterback Bryce Young may have the highest ceiling of all four QBs. Whilst the Saints do not have the stars, they do have an excellent wide receiver in Chris Olave. They also have the best knack for fourth quarter comebacks.
All four teams will face each other in divisional matchups, with the wins and losses likely to be evenly distributed. On paper, the Buccaneers have the easiest schedule. They do go up against the Detroit Lions and Los Angeles Rams, who represent tougher tasks, but they are also set to also take on the Los Angeles Chargers and Baltimore Ravens, two teams that have struggled this season.
Baltimore also takes on the Panthers, who also must face the Minnesota Vikings, Cincinnati Bengals and Seattle Seahawks, who are all set to be very present in the playoff bracket. The Chicago Bears are also one of these teams, and they will take on the Saints along with the Green Bay Packers and Bengals. Meanwhile, the Falcons also have matchups against the Lions and Vikings in addition to the Cleveland Browns, who are on a 6-4 record.
All four teams have their cases to win the division, with the Bucs and Panthers seen as the most likely. However, in this division, anything is possible.

ANDY DAVIES
NFL ANALYST
ANDY IS A SPORTS JOURNALISM GRADUATE WITH OVER SIX YEARS EXPERIENCE OF NFL WRITING AND PODCASTING. ANDY HAS BEEN TO EVERY NFL STADIUM AND IS THE HOST OF THE ACROSS THE POD PODCAST. HE HAS PRESS PASS EXPERIENCE AT THE LONDON GAMES AND MANY OTHER NFL BASED EVENTS SUCH AS SUPER BOWL LIX AND LX, HAVING INTERVIEWED THE LIKES OF AARON RODGERS, JUSTIN JEFFERSON, JASON BELL, OSI UMENYIORA, PATRICK MAHOMES, TRAVIS KELCE, DERRICK HENRY, SAQUON BARKLEY AND JALEN HURTS.
