Slightly shorter than desired for the NFL. Stout frame looks capable of adding needed body mass
Underwhelming athleticism – is not a running threat, and scrambling ability is modest
Operated almost exclusively out of the shotgun at Kalamazoo – potential transition growing pains
Benefited from a lot of short, manufactured backfield/shallow passes with good YAC potential
Not asked to work through a full slate of progressions often – plenty of half-field reads
Lower half body mechanics need addressing; lazy footwork & throws from inconsistent base
The Verdict:
“Kaleb Eleby reminds me so much of Philip Rivers it is unreal. A pocket passer with limited mobility but shifty enough to operate a vulnerable pocket, Eleby keeps his eyes downfield and throws with impeccable timing and accuracy. A rhythm passer who is difficult to stop when he gets going, NFL scouts will love the short , rapid throwing motion and how he leads the receiver into open space. In the modern pro game, Eleby’s draft stock may well be limited as teams look for an athletic quarterback capable of punishing sleeping defenses on the ground - something the former Bronco doesn’t have in his arsenal. There’ll be more asked of him mentally if he’s put in a traditional pro offense, but whilst that may slow his ascension his other smarts suggest he should be capable of such a transition. In a relatively weak QB class, Eleby might be the early day three pick that surprises everyone - there’s starter potential here.”
PREVIOUSLY THE FOUNDER OF NFL DRAFT UK, SIMON HAS BEEN COVERING COLLEGE FOOTBALL AND THE NFL DRAFT SINCE 2009. BASED IN MANCHESTER, SIMON IS ALSO CO-CREATOR & WEEKLY GUEST OF THE COLLAPSING POCKET PODCAST.