CFB: Notre Dame Fighting Irish Week 1 Preview

By Stiofán Mac Fhilib

Nine months and a day to the last time the Notre Dame football team took the field, in the Sun Bowl in El Paso, TX, the Irish return to the Lone Star State to kick-off their 2024 campaign with a tough road trip to College Station taking on the Texas A&M Aggies. 

With the new 12-team college football playoff format starting this December, a win may not be essential. But for third-year Head Coach Marcus Freeman and a program often rightly accused of not winning the big games, a win in front of over 100,000 passionate fans on a sultry Texas late August evening would send out a clear signal of intent for the most important season of his coaching career.

Looking back at last week

Embed from Getty Images

Not so much last week as just before the 2024 New Year. Both Notre Dame and Oregon State entered the Sun Bowl missing more than half a dozen key starters due to draft and transfer portal-related opt outs. It was the Irish who demonstrated the greater depth as they took a 14-0 half-time lead and rolled over the Beavers in the second half, en route to a 40-8 victory. 

Steve Angeli, who will back up Riley Leonard in 2024, threw for three TDs. And perhaps notably, four of ND’s five TDs came from players who will play key roles this season: WRs, Jordan Faison and Jayden Thomas, and RBs, Jeremiyah Love and Jadarian Price.

The week ahead

Embed from Getty Images
Texas A&M Aggies (Kyle Field, College Station, TX); 7.30pm EST; 12.30am IST/BST

This is just the sixth time these two storied programs have met, and only the third in the regular season. The Irish lead the series 3-2, though the Aggies won the most recent matchup, back in 2001, 24-3 in front of what was, at that time, the largest crowd ever to watch a football game in Texas.

ND now has two of the highest paid, and most experienced, co-ordinators in college football. Its veteran defense, with more than half the starters in Grad School, is expected to be at least in the top ten. And it has a more youthful but talented offense that used the transfer portal to significantly upgrade at skill positions. Thus, expectations are pretty high among the Notre Dame faithful.

And they would likely be even higher were it not for the Irish OL. Ironically this perennial strength of ‘OL U’ appears to be potentially its weakest unit. Three redshirt sophomores, a redshirt freshman and a true freshman, at LT no less, means the unit has a grand total of six career starts as it boards the plane down to Texas.

How well this group does as it improves during the season will decide how far into the playoffs Notre Dame can go. How well it can keep its head above water in College Station will determine if the Irish have the chance to go 12-0 and claim the coveted #5 playoff seeding.

What doesn’t help matters from an ND perspective is that the DL is the strength of the Aggies team. Their new Head Coach, Mike Elko, was a very effective DC at both Notre Dame and A&M, and while Jay Bateman came from UNC to be his DC now, expect Elko’s fingerprints to be all over the defensive gameplan on Saturday night.

Much of the stellar 2022 recruiting class has moved on, but plenty of talent remains. And then you can add DE, Nic Scourton, the Purdue transfer who led the Big Ten in sacks in 2023. ND’s new LT, Anthonie Knapp, is likely to become very well acquainted with the Aggies #11 this weekend.

LB Taurean York was a freshman All-American, though much of the rest of that room is made up of transfers, and how quickly they can gel may be something the Irish can exploit.

CB Tyreek Chappell and S Bryce Anderson anchor a very good secondary, though again, the introduction of several transfers may delay that unit from reaching its full potential immediately.

Offensively, the connections between the two programs continue. Collin Klein was a candidate for the OC position at Notre Dame when Tommy Rees left for Alabama. The Irish chose to go in a different direction, and ultimately, it was Elko who persuaded the former Wildcats quarterback to leave Kansas State for the SEC.

He has a five-star QB to work with, which is never a bad start.  Conner Weigman saw his 2023 season end with a foot injury after just four games but is healthy to go in 2024. A pocket passer, his eight starts to date have seen him throw 18 TDs and just 2 INTs.

He has the luxury of some elite speed at skill positions, though not necessarily huge production. Deep threat, Jadhae Walker, and Noah Thomas carry the biggest threat to the Irish secondary.

RB Le’Veon Moss will have an even greater burden to carry in the Aggies’ run game now, with the season-ending injury to five-star recruit Reuben Owens. But the biggest issue for A&M on offense mirrors their Notre Dame counterparts: just how effective will their OL play be?

They were poor in both the passing and run games last season. Several different combinations were tried, with the only consistency being the amount of pressure A&M QBs have been under. Elko brought his OL coach from Duke with him to College Station, and several transfers have come in. But at a position where chemistry and teamwork are vital, A&M OL may also have to wait until deeper into the season before seeing the best and most consistent version of itself.

Game Prediction

Notre Dame 20-17 Texas A&M

Both Defensive Lines will have their way for much of a low scoring game. Ultimately, however, Mike Denbrock’s ability to out-scheme Collin Klein, with Leonard’s legs in particular, will prove decisive in a hard-fought, narrow Irish victory.

Where to Watch:

Sky Sports Mix (Channel 416 on Sky); coverage starts at 12:30am IST/BST

ABC/ESPN+ (in the USA)

Playoff Picture

With the new 12-team playoff format, big, early season inter-conference matchups no longer carry quite the same degree of jeopardy for post-season hopes. Wins can be important resumé-boosters, but individual defeats are no longer quite as catastrophic. 

That said, Georgia-Clemson and USC-LSU are two key games that will help the playoff committee rank the upper echelons of the SEC, Big Ten and ACC come November. As the season progresses, I’ll look at how the playoff picture is shaping up, hopefully with the Irish included, and what ND fans should be looking for.  

STIOFÁN MAC FHILIB

COLLEGE FOOTBALL ANALYST

A VERY LONG-DISTANCE SUBWAY ALUMNUS OF NOTRE DAME, COUNTY ANTRIM-BASED STIOFÁN HAS BEEN A FAN OF THE FIGHTING IRISH SINCE 2000. FOLLOW HIM ON TWITTER @SMACFHILIB.

5/5