Wardy's NFL Wordy, Week 10: The Greatest Matches We Never Saw

By Rob Ward

Whilst catching up on the myriad of NFL podcasts I listen to – all of which pale in comparison to The Touchdown’s offerings (there’s my attempt at a pay rise) – I came across the inspiration for this week’s column. 

The podcast was previewing last weekend’s Packers-Patriots ‘Game of the Week’ and was introduced as such:

“Packers and Patriots, one of the great ‘what ifs’ in NFL history, as we never got the Rodgers Brady Super Bowl we were all hoping for…”

And it continued from there. But the small hamster in my small brain had jumped onto her wheel (yes, it’s a she hamster, I’m woke) and was powering up. Is Packers and Patriots, with the best two quarterbacks of at least two-thirds of that decade, the greatest Super Bowl of the 2010s that we never had? To save time going over every possible permutation, I’m going to say yes. 

Let’s go back and discover some more moments in time, when we were denied the greatest matches between Week 10’s competing teams? Be it Super Bowls, Championship Games or head to heads for the number one overall pick, where did those ships pass in the night and what did we miss because they didn’t collide (other than a load of dead seamen…stop laughing at the back)? 

Embed from Getty Images

NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS @ DETROIT LIONS (though actually @ Munich, Germany)

I haven’t given myself an easy one to start but, if you squint, you can see a Super Bowl in the mid 1990s where one of the best aerial attacks in the NFL squares off against the best running game in the league. Behind the arm of 1993 number one overall pick Drew Bledsoe, Bill Parcells’ Patriots were one of the best offenses in the league 1994-1996, around the same time Barry Sanders was winning OPOY and MVP recognition. Parcells got the Pats to Super Bowl XXXI, losing to Brett Favre’s Green Bay Packers, but despite Sanders’ brilliance, the Lions only made it past the Wildcard Round once in six 90s playoff appearances.

CAROLINA PANTHERS @ NEW ORLEANS SAINTS

The NFC South has not been good enough to accommodate more than one playoff team for a long time now, not since the heady days of the 2010s when Cam Newton, Matt Ryan and Drew Brees were signal callers. These two teams did lock horns in the Wildcard in 2017, but at that stage Cam Newton’s powers were greatly reduced. Four years earlier, however, Newton was on song and Luke Kuechly was the youngest DPOY the league had ever seen. The Panthers topped the South on 12-4, but the Saints were snapping at their heels at 11-5, the last throws of the 2009 fairytale Lombardi lifters.  Both made it to the Divisional Round, but the mighty defenses of the Seahawks and 49ers were too strong as the South fell to the West and, a few weeks later, the legend of the Legion of Boom was cemented in football history forever.

MIAMI DOLPHINS @ INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

We’re gonna have to get into our time machines for this one, to the Wildcard Round of the 1970 season, when the Colts played in Baltimore and the Dolphins played in… well, Miami. It’s too cold or dry for Dolphins in most other states. On the same weekend of a particularly entertaining Cowboys 5 Lions 0 match (1 field goal, 1 safety), the Dolphins lost a close one 21-14 in Oakland. In the 3rd quarter, with the Dolphins on offense in Raiders’ territory, QB Bob Griese took a costly 12-yard sack on 2nd down that forced him into a deeper throw than he was comfortable with on 3rd down. Griese threw it straight to Raiders’ cornerback Willie Brown, who promptly returned it to the house. A 14-point swing on one play. Without that, the Fins get the win and have the chance to stop legendary Colts quarterback Johnny Unitas from winning his only Super Bowl in the Championship Game. 

HOUSTON TEXANS @ CLEVELAND BROWNS

A tale of two cities that had teams taken from them before re-entering the league. Houston’s original team, the Oilers, were now in Tennessee and called the Titans. Cleveland’s original team were in Baltimore and now called the Ravens. Houston were now the Texans, but Cleveland were still the Browns, just not quite as Brown as the previous Browns. Or maybe more Brown, in fact, for they have been shit for most of the proceeding 24 years. The Texans have been decent – sometimes good – for most of their existence, but for this match we’re gonna reflect on a Toilet Bowl that never was. In 2003 the Browns and Texans both finished 5-11, alongside a host of other teams, meaning the usual tiebreakers came into play for the 2004 draft. Cleveland ended up picking at 7 and Houston were at 10. Had these teams met that regular season, whoever lost that game would have been bumped higher up the draft, avoiding the doomed picks they inevitably made of Kellen Winslow (Browns) or Dunta Robinson (Texans). Hey, I never said this exercise would lead to interesting results.

MINNESOTA VIKINGS @ GREEN BAY PACKERS

In 1998, the Packers had the DPOY in Reggie White along with the 1997 MVP Brett Favre, whilst the Vikes had Coach of the Year Dennis Green, OROY Randy Moss, with QB Randall Cunningham leading the highest scoring offense of the season. We were denied an offensive duel for the ages, however, as the Packers went down in the Wildcard to the final moment in the sun of Steve Young’s 49ers. A couple of weeks later, Minnesota had perhaps the most painful Championship Game loss in history, when kicker Gary Anderon missed his only kick of the season in defeat to the ‘Dirty Birds’ Atlanta Falcons.

Embed from Getty Images

JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS @ TENNESSEE TITANS

Jeez, how am I going to make this one exciting? It doesn’t help that the two franchises have mostly been turd, but they have played each other twice a season for the entire existence of the Jags, so I can’t conjure up an imaginary Toilet Bowl. The Toilet Bowls happened for real frequently, usually on Thursday Night Football. And the one season they were both good (1999), they end up meeting in the AFC Championship Game. No ‘what if?’ scenario needed there. I have no choice but to go back to the days when the Titans were the Oilers, who, in their final season in Houston (1996), defeat the Jags in the Astrodome in Week 15. Having done the double on the Jags, the Oilers leap the Jags into the playoffs and convince Oilers owner Bud Adams to stay in Houston. The Tennessee Titans don’t exist, neither to the Oilers’ replacement Texans, and the league is still at 31 teams. Who becomes the 32nd franchise? Turns out I can make this one exciting! 

BUFFALO BILLS @ NEW YORK JETS

We head back to 1998, the golden year for great matches we never saw. In the AFC Wild Card round, the Bills’ QB Doug Flutie fumbles the ball on the opposition Dolphins’ 5-yard line with 17 seconds to go and with a chance to tie the game. Let’s say he doesn’t cock up and the Bills come through; they then go to Denver in the Divisional Round. If there’s one team who can handle the January Denver chill, it’s a team from Buffalo. The Bills then face the Jets in the Championship Game, with the winner the automatic favourite to take down the overachieving Falcons in the Super Bowl. Bill Parcells coaches in a Super Bowl with his third different team (New York) and the Joe Naimath curse is put to bed. 

KANSAS CITY CHIEFS @ ATLANTA FALCONS

The Falcons have gone eight seasons without making the playoffs, whereas the Chiefs’ absence in 2026 was ended a run of ten consecutive years in the postseason. In the early days of that Chiefs run there was, however, a very good Falcons team. Perhaps the best ever assembled in Atlanta. The 2016 Falcons team were led by MVP Matt Ryan, had Julio Jones at his incomparable best and engineered by OC Kyle Shanahan. That same season, the Chiefs secured a bye by taking the AFC West 12-4 – with the emergence of superstars Travis Kelce, Tyreek Hill, Marcus Peters and Chris Jones – but dropped a bollock by losing to 6 Chris Boswell field goals the Divisional Round home defeat to the Steelers. Had the Chiefs come through the AFC, Atlanta may have lost the Super Bowl in bog standard fashion and Tom Brady wouldn’t have an obnoxious ring adorned with 283 diamonds. 

LOS ANGELES RAMS @ ARIZONA CARDINALS

Despite having the feel of an expansion team, the Cardinals have actually been going since 1920. They were the Racine Cardinals, the Chicago Cardinals, the St Louis Cardinals before landing in the desert in 1988, originally as the Phoenix Cardinals before settling, for now, on the Arizona Cardinals in 1994. And bless them, in all that time, they’ve been terrible. When in St Louis – the Cardinals that is, not the Rams (keep up!) – they had a decent mid 70s run under 1974 Coach of the Year Dan Coryell, winning the NFC East (Missouri in the east!?!) in ’74 and ’75. Under head coach Chuck Knox, the Rams, still in Los Angeles, made it all the way to the NFC Championship Game in 1974, powered by a Jack Youngblood led defense. In the Divisional Round, the Cardinals were holding their own against Minnesota’s Purple People Eater defense, until 7 minutes of 3rd quarter madness, when an interception and fumble recovery TD put the game beyond the Cards and denied us the greatest(ish) matchup we never saw between these modern-day NFC West divisional foes.

Embed from Getty Images

SEATTLE SEAHAWKS @ LAS VEGAS RAIDERS 

The Raiders have been bad for a quarter of a century now. The last great side they had, in the early-mid 80s, coincided with the Seahawks playing in the AFC and the two teams met in in three straight seasons between 1983 and 1985, including a Championship Game in Oakland’s ’83 Super Bowl winning season. Having scoured through every season I have to be honest, this is the fixture that has defeated me. There is NO great match we didn’t see between these sides, there isn’t even a Toilet Bowl that might have been. Worse still, I can’t even come up with a pithy or witty comment to sign off on. That aforementioned pay rise looks a long way off. 

SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS @ DALLAS COWBOYS 

From famine to feast. You could pick most seasons from the early 80s to the mid 90s, if you can find one where these teams didn’t meet. Naturally with this rivalry, we are drawn to the early-mid 90s. The Cowboys and 9ers played in three straight Championship Games 1992-1994, but damn it should have been four! In 1995, en route to a 3rd Lombardi in 4 years, the Cowboys crushed the Eagles in the Divisional and awaited the boys from the Bay. But Brett Favre’s Green Bay Packers had other ideas, marching into Candlestick Park and dethroning the reigning champs. Steve Young threw for a playoff record 65 passes that day but completed only half of them. There’s the ball game – and the dream rematch – right there.

PITTSBURGH STEELERS @ CINCINNATI BENGALS

The standout game of this weekend between two teams in the heart of rustbelt America. Ohio and Pennsylvania. Let’s go back in time to the craziest of NFL seasons, the 1982 strike interrupted year. The regular season campaign was cut in half and the Washington then Redskins prevailed, but there were so many ‘what might have beens’ throughout the league, none less so than in the then AFC Central. The Bengals were the reigning AFC Champs, downed  by the first Walsh-Montana 9ers in 1981, and the Steelers were in the transitional ‘we were good in the 70s and now it’s the 80s’ phase. Both sides lost Wildcard matches, but had we been treated to an earlier incarnation of the rivalry yet to come, in Terry Bradshaw’s final season, there was an easy route to Super Bowl glory against a run of the mill Washington side in Super Bowl XVII.

LOS ANGELES CHARGERS @ BALTIMORE RAVENS

If we ignore the years when the Ravens were the Cleveland Browns, controversial though that feels to type, we have to go back to 2008. The Chargers were the ascendent AFC team, led by QB Philip Rivers and RB Ladanian Tomlinson, whilst the Ravens first season under head coach John Harbaugh saw a ferocious Rex Ryan defense take the league by storm. Both fell to Mike Tomlin’s Steelers, but both can claim ‘what might have been’ status when you consider the Super Bowl contest against the Kurt Warner led underdog Cardinals. Harbaugh could have eclipsed Tomlin in the AFC North memory banks, whilst this was probably Rivers’ best chance at shimmying in the Big Dance. It wasn’t to be. Harbaugh went on to claim the Lombardi in 2012, whilst Rivers consoled himself by siring 30 more children. Who was the real winner?

ROB WARD

NFL/Fantasy Football Enthusiast

ROB IS A LOVER OF ALL THINGS 49ERS AND HOST OF THE COLLAPSING POCKET PODCAST IN WHICH HE, SIMON CARROLL AND SAM AKROYD BUTT-FUMBLE THEIR WAY THROUGH THE WORLD OF THE NFL. AWAY FROM SPORT, ROB IS A PROFESSIONAL WRITER AND PERFORMER. HIT HIM UP ON TWITTER @TDWARDY!

Rated 5 out of 5